箱式双向调压塔布设位置对水锤的影响Effect of placement locations of box-type bidirectional surge tanks on water hammer
秦若琪,史玮,徐一丁
Qin Ruoqi,Shi Wei,Xu Yiding
摘要(Abstract):
针对长距离输水管道水锤现象易引发管道破裂的工程问题,结合实际跨流域调水支线工程实例,探讨箱式双向调压塔布设位置对管道压力波动的控制效果。依托特征线法构建水力瞬态数值模型,对比仅前段布设、前段-中段联合布设、前-中-末三段联合布设3种调压方案。结果表明,仅前段布设调压塔时,管道压力超限长度26 560 m,超限占比83%,最大水锤压力峰值达2.551 MPa;前段与中段联合布设时,压力超限长度24 560 m,超限占比76.7%,仍存在大范围压力超标,水锤风险无法得到有效控制;采用前、中、末三段联合布置箱式双向调压塔方案,全管线最大水锤压力由2.551 MPa降至0.736 MPa以内,可快速响应瞬态压力变化,显著抑制水锤升压,使31.44 km全管段压力全部控制在1.0 MPa设计承压范围内,管道压力达标覆盖率达到100%。调压塔与水锤发生点近距离匹配布置可充分发挥动态稳压效能,防护效果最优。工程实际运行至今未发生由水锤造成的设备损坏与安全事故。研究成果可为长距离输水工程水锤防护设计与调压设施优化布局提供参考。
Addressing the engineering issue of pipeline rupture caused by water hammer in long-distance water conveyance pipelines, based on a practical case of an inter-basin water transfer branch project,explores the control effect of the placement location of box-type bidirectional surge tanks on pipeline pressure fluctuations. Utilizing the characteristic line method,a hydraulic transient numerical model is constructed to compare three surge regulation schemes:only front-section deployment,combined front-section and middle-section deployment,and combined front, middle, and end-section deployment. The results indicate that when only the front-section surge tank is deployed, the pipeline pressure exceeds the limit for a length of 26 560 m, accounting for 83% of the total length, with a maximum water hammer pressure peak reaching 2.551 MPa. When the front-section and middle-section surge tanks are jointly deployed,the pressure exceeds the limit for a length of 24 560 m,accounting for 76.7% of the total length, still resulting in widespread pressure exceedances and ineffective control of water hammer risks.By adopting the scheme of jointly deploying box-type bidirectional surge tanks in the front, middle, and end sections,the maximum water hammer pressure along the entire pipeline is reduced from 2.551 MPa to within 0.736 MPa.This arrangement allows for rapid response to transient pressure changes,significantly suppresses water hammer pressure rise,and ensures that the pressure of the entire 31.44 km pipeline section is controlled within the design pressure range of 1.0 MPa,with a pressure compliance coverage rate of 100%.The close proximity of the surge tanks to the water hammer occurrence points maximizes their dynamic pressure stabilization efficiency, achieving optimal protection effects.Since its actual operation, the project has not experienced any equipment damage or safety accidents caused by water hammer.The research findings provide valuable insights for the design of water hammer protection and the optimal layout of surge regulation facilities in long-distance water conveyance projects.
关键词(KeyWords):
水锤;箱式双向调压塔;布置位置
water hammer;box-type bidirectional surge tank;placement location
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Author):
秦若琪,史玮,徐一丁
Qin Ruoqi,Shi Wei,Xu Yiding
参考文献(References):
- [1]石林,张健,倪尉翔,等.具有特殊地形条件的长距离供水工程水锤防护[J].水力发电学报,2019,38(5):81-88.Shi L,Zhang J,Ni W X,et al. Water hammer protection of long-distance water supply projects with special terrain conditions[J].Journal of Hydroelectric Engineering,2019,38(5):81-88.
- [2]郭晓一,张晓雷,刘书瑜,等.某长距离输水工程调压井联合空气阀的关阀水锤防护研究[J].水电能源科学,2025,43(5):169-172。Guo X Y,Zhang X L,Liu S Y,et al. Study on the shut-off water hammer protection of the joint air valve of regulator wells in a long-distance water transfer project[J].Water Resources and Power,2025,43(5):169-172.
- [3]赵斌,胡斌超,刘有亮,等.长距离泵站水锤分析及管线布置对水锤的影响[J].排灌机械工程学报,2024,42(11):1112-1119.Zhao B,Hu B C,Liu Y L,et al. Analysis of water hammer phenomena phenomena in long-distance pumping stations and impact of pipeline configuration on its occurrence[J]. Journal of Drainage and Irrigation Machinery Engineering,2024,42(11): 1112-1119.
- [4]葛冠江,侯庆志,杨旭亮,等.基于SSA-XGBoost算法的停泵水锤防护优化[J].排灌机械工程学报,2025,43(10):1016-1022.Ge G J,Hou Q Z,Yang X L,et al.Research on pump shutdown water hammer protection optimization based on SSA-XGBoost algorithm[J]. Journal of Drainage and Irrigation Machinery Engineering,2025,43(10): 1016-1022.
- [5]石晓悟,何武全,李渤,等.山丘区自压输水管道水锤计算与模拟方法[J].排灌机械工程学报,2024,42(3):282-287.Shi X W,He W Q,Li B,et al. Calculation and simulation method for water hammer in gravity flow pipeline in hilly areas[J]. Journal of Drainage and Irrigation Machinery Engineering,2024,42(3):282-287.
- [6]杨春霞,李倩,马经童,等.多分水口长距离输水工程停泵水锤防护措施[J].排灌机械工程学报,2024,42(3): 250-255.Yang C X,Li Q,Ma J T,et al.Water hammer protection measures for long-distance water transmission projects during pump stop with multiple water diversions outlets[J]. Journal of Drainage and Irrigation Machinery Engineering,2024,42(3):250-255.
- [7]新湖南客户端.温馨提示:停水区域市民若急需用水可联系送水热线电话[EB/OL].(2021-01-04)[2026-05-17]. https://m. voc. com. cn/xhn/news/202101/17894834.html.
- [8]央广网.供水管道突发破裂呼和浩特市区大面积停水48 小时[EB/OL].(2024-03-10)[2026-05-17].https://nm. cnr. cn/gstjnmg/20240310/t20240310_526622614.shtml.
- [9] Menabrea L F.Note sur les effets de choc de l'eau dans les conduits[J].Comptes Rendus Hebdomadaires des Seances de l'Academie des Sciences,France,1858,47:221-224.
- [10] Wylie E B,Streeter V L. Fluid transients[M]. New York:McGraw-Hill International Book Company,1978.
- [11]刘竹溪,刘光临.泵站水锤及其防护[M].北京:水利电力出版社,1988.,Liu Z XLiu G L.Water hammer and protection in pumping stations[M]. Beijing:Water Resources and Electric Power Press,1988.
- [12]刘梅清,冯卫民.单向调压塔防水锤特性的数值模拟与研究[J].水利学报,1995(10):23-28.Liu M Q,Feng W M.Numerical simulation and study on the water hammer prevention characteristics of one-way surge tank[J]. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering,1995(10):23-28.
- [13]魏永庆,杨玉思.长距离输水管道的箱式双向调压塔技术探讨[J].水利水电技术,2010,41(10):45-47.Wei Y Q,Yang Y S. Discussion on box-type bidirectional surge tank technology for long-distance water transmission pipelines[J].Water Resources and Hydropower Engineering,2010,41(10):45-47.
- [14]王思琪,俞晓东,倪尉翔,等.长距离供水工程空气罐调压塔联合防护水锤[J].排灌机械工程学报,2019,37(5):406-412.Wang S Q,Yu X D,Ni W X,et al. Water hammer protection in long-distance water supply project with combined air vessel and surge tanks[J]. Journal of Drainage and Irrigation Machinery Engineering,2019,37(5):406-412.
- [15]梁兴,李燕,刘梅清,等.高扬程长爬坡泵系统水锤的防护[J].排灌机械工程学报,2023,41(12):1232-1236.Liang X,Li Y,Liu M Q,et al. Water hammer protection of pump system with high head and long climb[J]. Journal of Drainage and Irrigation Machinery Engineering,2023,41(12):1232-1236.
- [16]田杨.大管径平坦管道水锤防护技术的特点[D].西安:长安大学,2014.Tian Y.The characteristics of water hammer protection technology in heavy caliber and flow flat water supply pipe[D].Xi'an:Chang'an University,2014.
- [17]王祺武,李志鹏,朱慈东,等.重力流输水管路阀门调节与水锤控制分析[J].流体机械,2020,48(6):38-43,50.Wang Q W,Li Z P,Zhu C D, et al.Analysis on valve regulation and water hammer control of gravity flow pipeline[J]. Fluid Machinery,2020,48(6):38-43,50.
- [18]吴猛猛,孙团,李刚.水下航行体压力管道水锤及预防措施研究[J].机床与液压,2019,47(6):33-37.Wu M M,Sun T,Li G.Research on the water hammer of underwater vehicle pressure water pipeline and its prevention measures[J].Machine Tool&Hydraulics,2019,47(6):33-37.
- [19]丁家乐,杨明伟.基于Bentley Hammer的长距离有压管道输水工程的水锤防护研究[J].河南科技,2024,51(5):32-38.Ding J L,Yang M W. Research on water hammer protection for long-distance pressurized pipeline water transmission project based on Bentley Hammer[J].Henan Science and Technology,2024,51(5):32-38.
- [20]杨开林.空气阀水力瞬变数学模型[J].水利学报,2023,54(7):775-784.Yang K L. Mathematical models for hydraulic transients of air valves[J]. Journal of Hydraulic Engineering,2023,54(7):775-784.
- [21]宋思怡.长距离大管径输水管道水锤防护研究[D].西安:长安大学,2015.Song S Y. Research on water hammer prevention of long-distance,heavy calibre flow water supply pipe[D].Xi'an:Chang'an University,2015.
- [22]王航,陈帝伊,雷刘伟,等.兼顾调节特性和经济成本的调压室体型优化策略[J].中国农村水利水电,2024,(6):259-265.Wang H,Chen D Y,Lei L W,et al. A strategy for optimizing surge chamber body shape with balance between regulation characteristics and economic cost[J].China Rural Water and Hydropower,2024,(6):259-265.
- [23]刘小波,余瑞峰,刘思若,等.调压井与排气阀联合作用下水锤防护特性研究[J].水利规划与设计,2022(3):96-100,117.Liu X B,Yu R F,Liu S R,et al. Study on water hammer protection characteristics under combined action of surge shaft and air valve[J]. Water Resources Planning and Design,2022(3):96-100,117.
- [24]刘冬.河北南水北调廊涿长距离多支管重力流输水系统水锤防护设计计算[D].西安:长安大学,2013.Liu D. Design and calculation of Hebei LangZhuo water hammer protection of long distance water gravitational transportation pipeline system[D].Xi'an:Chang'an University,2013.
- [25]周云龙,李书芳,辛凯.长输浆体管路停泵水锤的研究[J].流体机械,2013,41(8):26-30.Zhou Y L,Li S F,Xin K. Research on long distance slurry pipeline pump-off water hammer[J]. Fluid Machinery,2013,41(8):26-30.
- [26]门妮.长距离多起伏压力输水管道水锤防护方案的研究[D].西安:长安大学,2015.Men N. Study on water hammer protection scheme of long-distance undulating pressurized water conveyance pipelines[D]. Xi'an: Chang'an University,2015.