基于有限元模型的大型机组N+1转子轴系虚拟动平衡方法Virtual dynamic balancing method for N+1 rotor shaft systems of large units based on finite element model
张子桐,潘鑫,卢加乔,杨柳青
Zhang Zitong,Pan Xin,Lu Jiaqiao,Yang Liuqing
摘要(Abstract):
针对大型汽轮发电机组N+1转子轴系结构的不平衡振动问题,以汽轮发电机组2+1转子实验台为研究对象,采用理论分析、数值仿真与试验验证相结合的方法开展系统性研究。基于有限元法(FEM)建立了N+1转子轴系的运动方程和等效动力学模型,并通过2+1转子实验台验证了模型的有效性;基于此模型,对N+1转子系统进行了动力学特性分析,研究模型参数对临界转速的影响,并探究了在轴系轴向不同位置施加不平衡量对轴系振动的影响规律;同时,利用有限元模型的稳态响应结果,在900 r/min和1 500 r/min工况下通过虚拟动平衡试验,对比了仿真与实测影响系数。结果表明,所有测点中,幅值的最大误差为7.82%(实测值0.224μm/g,仿真值0.243μm/g);相位最大误差为8.73%(实测值349.21°,仿真值382.61°),较好地验证了虚拟动平衡技术在N+1转子系统应用中的可行性。研究可为大型机组N+1转子系统的轴系动平衡提供理论参考与技术支撑。
To address the unbalanced vibration problem of N+1 rotor shaft systems in large turbogenerator units,a 2+1 rotor experimental bench of a turbogenerator unit was taken as the research object,and a systematic study was carried out by combining theoretical analysis,numerical simulation,and experimental verification.Based on the finite element method(FEM),the motion equations and equivalent dynamic model of the N+1 rotor shaft system were established,and the validity of the model was verified through the 2+1 rotor experimental bench.Based on this model,the dynamic characteristics of the N+1 rotor system were analyzed,the influence of model parameters on the critical speed was studied,and the influence law of applying unbalance at different axial positions of the shaft system on shaft vibration was investigated.Meanwhile, using the steady-state response results of the finite element model,virtual dynamic balancing tests were conducted under the operating conditions of 900 r/min and 1 500 r/min,and the simulation and measured influence coefficients were compared. The results show that among all measurement points,the maximum amplitude error is 7.82%(measured value 0.224 μm/g,simulated value 0.243 μm/g);the maximum phase error is 8.73%(measured value 349.21°,simulated value 382.61°),which well verifies the feasibility of applying the virtual dynamic balancing technique to the N+1 rotor system.This study can provide theoretical reference and technical support for shaft dynamic balancing of N+1 rotor systems in large units.
关键词(KeyWords):
N+1转子轴系;有限元动力学模型;轴系动力学特性;虚拟动平衡
N+1 rotor shaft system;finite element dynamic model;shaft system dynamic characteristics;virtual dynamic balancing
基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金项目(52505083)
作者(Author):
张子桐,潘鑫,卢加乔,杨柳青
Zhang Zitong,Pan Xin,Lu Jiaqiao,Yang Liuqing
参考文献(References):
- [1]宾光富,崔亚辉,姚剑飞,等.1 000 MW汽轮机组N+1支撑轴系高压转子轴端汽封碰摩故障特性分析[J].润滑与密封,2017,42(8):100-104.Bin G F,Cui Y H,Yao J F,et al.Study on steam seal rubbing fault characteristics for high-pressure rotor of 1 000 MW steam turbine shafting with N+1 supports[J].Lubrication Engineering,2017,42(8):100-104.
- [2]胡航领,何立东,王晨阳.2N和N+1支撑三跨转子在三种联轴器下的振动特性实验研究[J].振动与冲击,2017,36(5):164-168.Hu H L,He L D,Wang C Y. Tests for vibration characteristics of a N-span&2N-support rotor system and a N-span&(N+1)-support one connected with three kinds of coupling[J]. Journal of Vibration and Shock,2017,36(5):164-168.
- [3]姚剑飞.透平机械转子轴系振动故障特性分析及靶向抑制研究[D].北京:北京化工大学,2015.Yao J F.Study on vibration fault feature analysis and target control of vibration in the rotor-shaft system of turbomachinery[D]. Beijing:Beijing University of Chemical Technology,2015.
- [4]宾光富,何立东,高金吉,等.基于模态振型分析的大型汽轮机低压转子高速动平衡方法[J].振动与冲击,2013,32(14):87-92.Bin G F,He L D,Gao J J,et al.High-speed dynamic balancing method for low pressurerotor of a large steam turbine based on modal shape analysis[J].Journal of Vibration and Shock,2013,32(14):87-92.
- [5]王展,涂伟,张珂,等.高速主轴动平衡方法研究现状[J].现代制造工程,2019(6):154-160.Wang Z,Tu W,Zhang K,et al.The research situation of dynamic balancing method for high speed spindle[J]. Modern Manufacturing Engineering,2019(6):154-160.
- [6]王维民,高金吉,江志农,等.旋转机械无试重现场动平衡原理与应用[J].振动与冲击,2010,29(2):212-215.Wang W M,Gao J J,Jiang Z N,et al. Principle and application of no trial weight field balancing for a rotating machinery[J]. Journal of Vibration and Shock,2010,29(2):212-215.
- [7] Lu J Q,Zhang X,Pan X,et al. Research on unbalanced vibration suppression method for coupled cantilever dual-rotor system[J].Machines,2022,10(9):758.
- [8]曾梁彬,孙宇,彭斌彬.基于动态响应的高速压力机综合平衡优化[J].中国机械工程,2010,21(18):2143-2148.Zeng L B,Sun Y,Peng B B. Synthetic dynamic balance optimization of high speedpunch based on dynamic response[J].China Mechanical Engineering,2010,21(18):2143-2148.
- [9] Zhang Y,Xie Z L,Zhai L J,et al.Unbalanced vibration suppression of a rotor with rotating-frequency faults using signal purification[J].Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing,2023,190:110153.
- [10] Springer H,Ecker H,Gunter E J.Nonlinear unbalance response and stability thresholds of a warped multimass rotor in misaligned bearings[C]//Heslington,England:International Conference on Vibrations in Rotating Machinery,1984:499-506.
- [11]苏引平,曾庆猛,傅行军.主跨支撑特性对三支撑结构振动的影响[J].动力工程学报,2014,34(3):205-209.Su Y P,Zeng Q M,Fu X J. Effects of main-span supporting characteristics onvibration of the three-bearing structure[J].Journal of Chinese Society of Power Engineering,2014,34(3):205-509.
- [12]沈意平,宾光富,王钢,等.透平机械三转子四支撑轴系不平衡振动特性[J].振动、测试与诊断,2018,38(5):985-990.Shen Y P,Bin G F,Wang G,et al. Vibration characteristics for unbalance of turbomachinery shafting with three-rotor and four-support[J].Journal of Vibration,Measurement&Diagnosis,2018,38(5):985-990.
- [13]潘鑫,葛德宏,李薇,等.气压液式自愈调控系统性能分析与试验研究[J].流体机械,2024,52(1):1-6.Pan X,Ge D H,Li W,et al.Performance analysis and experimental study of pneumatic-liquid selfrecovery control system of turbo-generator unit[J]. Fluid Machinery,2024,52(1):1-6.
- [14]刘江,马宏伟,杨清华,等.大型透平压缩机组叶轮裂纹故障的监测分析与诊断[J].流体机械,2016,44(1):54-59.Liu J,Ma H W,Yang Q H,et al.Monitoring analysis and diagnosis of the impeller crack of a large turbine-driven compressor[J].Fluid Machinery,2016,44(1):54-59.
- [15]张振杰,赵金月,常学森,等.流体机械转子系统非线性振动机理研究[J].流体机械,2024,52(1):56-61.Zhang Z J,Zhao J Y,Chang X S,et al.Study on nonlinear vibration mechanism of fluid machinery rotor system[J]. Fluid Machinery,2024,52(1):56-61.
- [16]韩彦广,周雪斌,李旭,等.上汽西门子1 000 MW超超临界汽轮发电机组轴系振动特性[J].湖南电力,2010,30(增刊1):60-64.Han Y G,Zhou X B,Li X,et al.Characteristics of shaft system vibration of Siemens for 1 000 MW ultrasupercritical steam units[J]. Hunan Electric Power,2010,30(S1):60-64.
- [17]吴文青,谢诞梅,杨毅,等.具有初始弯曲的1 000 MW汽轮机低压转子的振动特征分析[J].振动与冲击,2014,33(17):150-153.Wu W Q,Xie D M,Yang Y,et al.Vibration behavior of a LP rotor with initial bending in a 1 000 MW turbine[J]. Journal of Vibration and Shock,2014,33(17):150-153.
- [18]高庆水,邓小文,张楚,等.单支撑1 000 MW超超临界汽轮机轴系不平衡响应分析[J].振动与冲击,2014,33(14):201-205.Gao Q S,Deng X W,Zhang C,et al. Unbalance response of 1 000 MW ultra supercriticalturbine with single bearing support[J]. Journal of Vibration and Shock,2014,33(14):201-205.
- [19]白堃.连续三支撑(N+1支撑)轴系振动特性研究[D].南京:东南大学,2021.Bai K. Study on vibration characteristics of shaftingsystem with continuous three braces(N+1 braces)[D].Nanjing:Southeast University,2021.
- [20]宾光富,李学军,沈意平,等.基于动力学有限元模型的多跨转子轴系无试重整机动平衡研究[J].机械工程学报,2016,52(21):78-86.Bin G F,Li X J,Shen Y P,et al. Whole-machine dynamic balancing method without trial weights for multi-span rotor shafting based on dynamic finite element model[J]. Chinese Journal of Mechanical Engineering,2016,52(21):78-86.
- [21]廖明夫.航空发动机转子动力学[M].西安:西北工业大学出版社,2015.Liao M F. Rotor dynamics of aircraft engines[M].Xi'an:Northwestern Polytechnical University Press,2015.
- [22]赵常青.风车不平衡模拟转子实验台的动力学特性研究[D].天津:中国民航大学,2018.Zhao C Q. Study on the dynamic characteristics of simulating rotor test rig in wind milling imbalance[D].Tianjin:Civil Aviation University of China,2018.
- [23] Goodman T P. A least-squares method for computing balance correction[J].Journal of Manufacturing Science and Engineering,1964,86(3):273-277.
- N+1转子轴系
- 有限元动力学模型
- 轴系动力学特性
- 虚拟动平衡
N+1 rotor shaft system - finite element dynamic model
- shaft system dynamic characteristics
- virtual dynamic balancing