脱硫废水离子浓度对管壁结垢行为的影响Effect of ion concentration of desulfurization wastewater on scaling behavior of tube wall
李仟龙,陈丽娟,魏博,谢伟智,马瑞,宋丽洁,双景轩,王建江
Li Qianlong,Chen Lijuan,Wei Bo,Xie Weizhi,Ma Rui,Song Lijie,Shuang Jingxuan,Wang Jianjiang
摘要(Abstract):
针对脱硫废水引起的管壁结垢问题,通过配置不同浓度离子溶液模拟实际工况,采用挂片沉积法对管壁结垢规律进行试验研究,结合结垢形貌系统分析接触时间与离子浓度对20钢结垢行为的影响。结果表明,挂片在模拟脱硫废水中主要发生CaSO_4结垢,且结垢过程遵循成核-生长机制;Ca~(2+)和SO_4~(2-)浓度的增加会加重结垢;Mg~(2+)浓度在0~4 000 mg/L范围内对结垢起明显的抑制作用,当Mg~(2+)浓度为4 000 mg/L时,相较于0 mg/L结垢量降低了65.3%,但浓度高于4 000 mg/L后反而会加重结垢;Cl~-浓度在20 000 mg/L之前结垢量缓慢减少,进一步增加时结垢量显著增加,Cl~-浓度为35 000 mg/L时较20 000 mg/L结垢量增加了74.2%。实际生产中,建议将Mg~(2+)和Cl~-浓度分别控制在4 000 mg/L和20 000 mg/L以下,以减缓管壁的结垢情况。研究可为脱硫废水处理工艺参数优化与高效防垢技术开发提供参考。
Aiming at the problem of tube wall scaling caused by desulfurization wastewater,the actual working conditions were simulated by configuring different concentration ion solutions.An experimental study on the scaling pattern of pipelines was conducted using the hanging-film deposition method.Combined with the scaling morphology,the effects of contact time and ion concentration on the scaling of 20 steel were systematically investigated.The results indicate that the main scaling phenomenon occurring on the coupon in simulated desulfurization wastewater is CaSO_4 scaling,which follows a nucleation-growth mechanism.The increase of Ca~(2+) and SO_4~(2-) concentration will aggravate the scaling.Mg~(2+) had a significant inhibitory effect on scaling at 0~4 000 mg/L,when the concentration of Mg~(2+) is 4 000 mg/L,the fouling amount is reduced by 65.3% compared with that of 0 mg/L,but it would still aggravate scaling when the concentration was higher than 4 000 mg/L.Before the Cl~- concentration reaches 20 000 mg/L,the amount of scaling decreases slowly.When the Cl~- concentration increases further from 20 000 mg/L,the amount of scaling increases significantly,when the concentration of Cl~- was 35 000 mg/L,the fouling amount increased by 74.2% compared with that of 20 000 mg/L.In actual production,it is recommended to control the concentration of Mg~(2+) below 4 000 mg/L and the concentration of Cl~- below 20 000 mg/L to mitigate tube wall scaling.The research can provide reference for the optimization of wastewater treatment process parameters and the development of efficient anti-scaling technology.
关键词(KeyWords):
脱硫废水;20钢;结垢;垢层形貌
desulfurization wastewater;20 steel;scaling;scale layer morphology
基金项目(Foundation): 国家自然科学基金项目(52261022);; 高校青年教师科研创新能力支持项目(SRICSPYF-BS2025042);; 国家级大学生创新训练计划项目(202510755044)
作者(Author):
李仟龙,陈丽娟,魏博,谢伟智,马瑞,宋丽洁,双景轩,王建江
Li Qianlong,Chen Lijuan,Wei Bo,Xie Weizhi,Ma Rui,Song Lijie,Shuang Jingxuan,Wang Jianjiang
参考文献(References):
- [1] Wang Y R,Zhan L X,Chen H,et al. Study on the evaporation performance of concentrated desulfurization wastewater and its products analysis[J]. Journal of Water Process Engineering,2024,58:104862.
- [2] Chen H,Hou D W,Zhan L X,et al.A demonstration project for desulfurization wastewater evaporation technology:Field test and performance analysis[J].Journal of Water Process Engineering,2023,53:103874.
- [3]李响.石灰石石膏湿法脱硫废水浓缩蒸发及氯迁移研究[D].杭州:浙江大学,2018.Li X. Study on wastewater concentration,evaporation and Cl migration for wet flue gas desulfurization system[D].Hangzhou:Zhejiang University,2018.
- [4]李正超,张燕玲,詹道平,等.湿法脱硫废水多污染物深度净化及作用机制[J].中国环境科学,2025,45(6):3073-3083.Li Z C,Zhang Y L,Zhan D P,et al.Deep purification for multiple pollutants in wet desulphurization wastewater[J]. China Environmental Science,2025,45(6):3073-3083.
- [5] Lu K,LüY,Bai Y X,et al.Experimental investigation and theoretical modeling on scale behaviors of high salinity wastewater in zero liquid discharge process of coal chemical industry[J]. Chinese Journal of Chemical Engineering,2020,28(4):969-979.
- [6] Jiang J X,Zhu F,Li K J,et al.Calcium sulfate scale control technology for circulating cooling water systems:A review[J]. Journal of Industrial and Engineering Chemistry,2025,152:58-74.
- [7]陈静,孔范洋,许铁群,等.裂解炉稀释蒸汽管道三通开裂原因分析[J].压力容器,2024,41(7):56-62.Chen J,Kong F Y,Xu T Q,et al.Analysis of cracking cause of the tee in diluted steam tube of cracking furnace[J].Pressure Vessel Technology,2024,41(7):56-62.
- [8]宋晓俊,杨忠武,豆磊,等.S31603复合板压力容器点蚀行为试验研究[J].压力容器,2024,41(3):8-16.Song X J,Yang Z W,Dou L,et al.Experimental and research on pitting corrosion behavior of S31603composite plate pressure vessel[J]. Pressure Vessel Technology,2024,41(3):8-16.
- [9] Xi Y T,Li Y D,Yao Y,et al. Identification and analysis of corrosion mechanisms for ground pipelines with hanging rings[J].Coatings,2022,12(9):1257.
- [10] Zhang L L,Gong Z B,Lin L L,et al.Corrosion-induced CaCO3 fouling in steel tube of oilfield wastewater treatment and the interfacial bonding mechanism:An experimental and theoretical investigation[J].Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering,2021,205:108759.
- [11]寇迪.油田污水处理管线钢腐蚀与结垢协同作用机制研究[D].西安:西安石油大学,2022.Kou D. Study on the synergistic mechanism of corrosion and scaling of oilfield water treatment pipeline steel[D]. Xi'an:Xi'an Shiyou University,2022.
- [12]王志坤,胡杨曼曼,屈文强,等.含硫油田井筒腐蚀结垢规律分析及防治措施研究[J].化学工程师,2024,38(11):82-86.Wang Z K,Hu Y M M,Qu W Q,et al.Analysis and prevention measures for corrosion and scaling in wellbore of sulfur-containing oilfield[J]. Chemical Engineer,2024,38(11):82-86.
- [13]侯园超.气田回注水管道结垢腐蚀动力学规律研究[D].北京:北京化工大学,2021.Hou Y C.Research on scaling corrosion kinetic law of reinjection water pipeline in gas field[D]. Beijing:Beijing University of Chemical Technology,2021.
- [14]郑豪.矿井水结垢特性及其软化应用研究[D].太原:太原理工大学,2023.Zheng H. Study on scaling characteristics and softening application of coal mine water[D].Taiyuan:Taiyuan University of Technology,2023.
- [15] Hu Q F,Zhou J H,Su Z,et al. Mechanisms of corrosion and corrosion scale formation in water supply networks:A review[J]. Journal of Water Process Engineering,2025,75:107975.
- [16] Anshar M A,Musa B,Ayaz M,et al.A critical review on corrosion and fouling of water in water distribution networks and their control[J].Acta chimica Slovenica,2023,70(2):173-183.
- [17]袁宗海.全厂废水零排放对石膏结晶的影响[D].北京:华北电力大学,2021.Yuan Z H. Effect of zero liquid discharge of whole plant wastewater on gypsum crystallization[D].Beijing:North China Electric Power University,2021.
- [18] Li B,Yun Y B,Liu G C,et al. Direct contact membrane distillation with softening pre-treatment for effective reclaiming flue gas desulfurization wastewater[J].Separation and Purification Technology,2021,277:119637.
- [19]刘绍轲.脱硫废水溶液换热器结垢特性及除垢方法研究[D].秦皇岛:燕山大学,2024.Liu S K. Research on scaling characteristics and descaling methods for heat exchangers used in desulfurization wastewater solutions[D].Qinhuangdao:Yanshan University,2024.
- [20]路凯.煤化工含盐废水处理管线结垢过程及机理研究[D].银川:宁夏大学,2019.Lu K. Research on pipeline fouling process and mechanism of coal chemical salty wastewater treatment[D].Yinchuan:Ningxia University,2019.
- [21] LüY,Lu K,Bai Y X,et al.Fouling characteristics of90°elbow in high salinity wastewater from coal chemical industry[J]. Chinese Journal of Chemical Engineering,2021,35:143-151.
- [22] Taherdangkoo R,Tian M M,Sadighi A,et al.Experimental data on solubility of the two calcium sulfates gypsum and anhydrite in aqueous solutions[J].Data,2022,7(10):140.
- [23]刘峰,张宏,宋扬.基于液固两相流的过滤器冲蚀磨损数值模拟[J].流体机械,2019,47(2):29-33.Liu F,Zhang H,Song Y. Numerical simulation of erosion wear of filter based on liquid/solid two-phase flow[J].Fluid Machinery,2019,47(2):29-33.
- [24]王勇,曾涛,徐银香,等.固体颗粒对水力旋流器冲蚀磨损特性的影响[J].流体机械,2019,47(5):50-55.Wang Y,Zeng T,Xu Y X,et al.Effect of solid particles on the erosion wear characteristics of hydrocyclone[J].Fluid Machinery,2019,47(5):50-55.
- [25]贾彩云.石膏利用的结晶学基础[D].杭州:浙江大学,2021.Jia C Y. Crystallography of gypsum utilization-mechanism investigation on nucleation and initial growth of calcium sulfate[D]. Hangzhou:Zhejiang University,2021.
- [26]范金福,刘猛,张晓辰,等.流速对垢下腐蚀的影响及其腐蚀机理[J].腐蚀与防护,2019,40(11):810-815.Fan J F,Liu M,Zhang X C,et al.Effect of velocity on the under-deposit corrosion and its corrosion mechanism[J].Corrosion&Protection,2019,40(11):810-815.
- [27]张国东,肖茂,崔伟,等.20#钢在不同碳源条件下硫酸盐还原菌腐蚀行为[J].压力容器,2024,41(10):50-58.Zhang G D,Xiao M,Cui W,et al.Corrosion of 20#steel via sulfate-reducing bacteria under different carbon source conditions[J]. Pressure Vessel Technology,2024,41(10):50-58.
- [28]艾芳芳,陈义庆,王储,等.H2S分压对SA387M Gr.11CL2(H)炼化管道用钢腐蚀行为的影响[J].压力容器,2024,41(8):47-55.Ai F F,Chen Y Q,Wang C,et al.Effect of H2S partial pressure on corrosion behavior of SA387M Gr. 11CL2(H)refining pipeline steel[J]. Pressure Vessel Technology,2024,41(8):47-55.
- [29]刘道宽.低温烟气浓缩脱硫废水关键问题研究[D].北京:华北电力大学,2022.Liu D K. Research on key issues of desulfurization wastewater concentration using low temperature flue gas[D]. Beijing:North China Electric Power University,2022.
- [30] Zeng Y H,Cao X M,Liu J,et al. Irreversible membrane damage resulting from the scaling of calcium sulfate in membrane distillation:Mechanistic duality of sodium chloride as a background electrolyte[J].Water research,2026,292:125351.